top of page

5 Housing Facts To Win Thanksgiving

11 minutes ago
8 min read

By the time you’re watching this, the Friday before Thanksgiving, I’ll be on the other side of the world chasing my offspring around Big Ben.  But you know your girl wasn’t going to leave you hanging.  Not when next Thursday you are going to be in a room with people who share your DNA and almost none of your opinions.


At some point somebody is going to say something about politics, and the temperature in that room is going to change, and you are going to want to choose violence.


Here’s your exit strategy, from the conversation (I can’t get you out of the house).


Steer the whole table onto housing, which is a subject everybody has a strong opinion about and almost nobody has read a single number on. Five facts. Each one of them is true, each one of them is counterintuitive, and each one of them will dismantle whatever your most overly-confident relative is about to announce between the first and second helping.


You get to change the subject and win. Happy Thanksgiving.


1. Sales have collapsed. Prices have not.


Your uncle has merged those into one story, and they are two different events.


Existing home sales in October came in at an annual pace of 3.75 million, down 5.5% from September and 8.8% from a year ago. That is the slowest pace since August 2010. But in that same month, the median sale price rose 0.4% to $416,700, which is an all-time high for the month of October in data going back to 1999.


Ain’t that a kick in the pants. The worst sales month in sixteen years, and the most expensive October ever recorded?!


So when somebody at the table says the housing market is crashing, the honest answer is that the transactions crashed. The values did not. Those are separate things, and poor financial decisions come from people confusing separate facts.


What is actually happening is a market that froze. Everybody is still here. Sellers are here and they want to move. Buyers are here and they want to buy. They are standing across from each other and neither one will go first.  That’s uniquely 2026 and should spark an interesting conversation. Dead means people left. Frozen means they stayed and stopped moving. You can thaw a frozen market way easier than you can resurrect a dead one.


2. The 2008 comparison dies on a single number.


Somebody is going to say this feels like 2008. It always happens but you only need one stat to curb that convo.


In 2010, foreclosures and short sales were 26% of all home sales. Last month, distressed sales were 2%.


Same sales pace as what we are seeing right now but a completely different market underneath it.


In 2010 the market was choking on forced sellers. People had to get out, at any price, and that is what drove values down. Today almost nobody has to sell. The typical seller has owned their home for twelve years, an all-time high, and they are sitting on equity and a mortgage rate they like.


A market where nobody has to sell does not crash. It freezes.  Reference talking point 1.


Inventory did rise to 1.59 million, the highest since November 2019, and supply is at 5.1 months. That is healthy and it is good news for buyers. It is also a very different thing from a distressed market on the brink of collapse.


3. The Fed matters less to housing every single year, and nobody has noticed.


This is the one that will actually stop the table, because everybody has been trained to think the Fed controls housing.


The Fed has exactly one real tool. It raises and lowers the cost of borrowing money. That tool works really well… on people who need to borrow.



  • Cash. About one in four buyers paid cash this year. In 2019 that number was 12%.


  • Repeat buyers. Repeat buyers are 78% of all purchases, and 30% of them are not borrowing at all.


  • Age. The median repeat buyer in America is 62 years old. In 1981 they were 36.


  • First-timers. First-time buyers were 29% of October sales, down from 32% a year ago.


So the Fed raises rates to cool housing demand, and a quarter of the market does not receive the message, because they are paying all cash.


The part of the market that does get cooled is the first-time buyer. The one without equity, the least flexibility, and no say in any of it. Rates are deciding who is allowed to participate in this market rather than cooling it evenly, and the same group keeps losing.


Say that at the table and watch what happens. I bet nobody has an argument ready for it, because it hasn’t made it to Fox or CNN yet.


4. I want the Fed to hike half a point, and here is my bet.


This is the part where I lose a few of you, and that’s ok.  


The Fed meets December 8 and 9. The market has a hike fully priced, and pricing now assumes two of them. Mortgage rates already took the beating for that in the last two weeks.


Fed Governor Christopher Waller said he leans toward a quarter point, but that a half point should be considered if core inflation came in around 0.3 percent or higher. October core came in at exactly 0.3 percent. He set the threshold and the data walked right up to it.


So the real question is no longer whether they hike. It’s how much will they hike?



If the Fed goes a full half point and the language makes clear they are serious about killing inflation, I think mortgage rates improve on the news.


The reason is that your mortgage rate does not follow the Fed funds rate. It follows the 10-year Treasury, which is priced off what the bond market believes inflation will do over the next decade. The bond market does not fear a rate hike. It fears inflation that nobody addresses.


A quarter point says we are nervous. A half point says we are finished playing. If the bond market believes the second one, long-term inflation expectations come down, the 10-year falls, and mortgage rates follow it down even as the Fed raises.


I might be wrong. It is still a much safer dinner conversation than whatever Trump posts that morning on Truth Social.


5. Asking prices have fallen for 43 straight weeks.


Now the part I actually care about, because this is the one with money attached to it.


Everybody is watching sale prices, which are basically flat. What about list prices, which have been falling for the better part of a year?


The median list price is now just under $410,000, down 1.2% from a year ago. That is the 43rd consecutive week of year-over-year declines in asking prices.  At the same time, new listings fell 10.3% from a year ago, the sixth straight monthly decline, while active inventory rose 8.3% because so little is selling. Homes are taking a median 65 days.


Long story short - fewer sellers are coming to market, but the ones already here have been sitting for two months and have watched their asking price drift down for most of a year. They are tired. And the number of buyers competing with you for them is the smallest it has been in sixteen years.


Which Brings Me to the Lowball Offer


Somebody at that table is going to tell a story about an insulting offer they got, or one they were too embarrassed to make. This is the most useful section in this blog, so let me take both sides.


If you are the seller and a lowball just landed…


Your first instinct is to be offended and counter at full list. That instinct is going to cost you money.


In a market where the median home sits 65 days, an offer is information. Somebody out there is paying enough attention to your house to put their name on a piece of paper. Insulting or otherwise, that is the only lead you have.


  1. Take a moment to breathe and gain clarity.


  2. Stop negotiating on price and start negotiating on structure.


If a buyer asks you to come down $15,000, you have two ways to give them the same $15,000. You can cut your price, which saves them roughly a hundred dollars a month and costs you the entire amount off your net.  They are likely going to come back later in escrow, probably after inspections and try to shake you down for more. Or you can leave your price alone and fund a rate buydown with the same money, which can take four or five hundred dollars a month off their payment in the early years and gives them real breathing room.


Same dollars out of your pocket. Wildly different effect on the buyer’s morale.


Before you respond to anything, know three numbers: your true net at their offer, your true net at your counter, and what the buyer's payment looks like under each.


If you are the buyer about to make one


A low number with nothing attached to it gets rejected on principle. A low number with reasoning attached gets countered, and a counter is the whole game.


Three things change the outcome.


  • Show your work. Send the comps and the repair estimates with the offer. You are giving the seller a story they can tell themselves about why this is reasonable, which is what they actually need in order to say yes.


  • Sell your certainty. In this market, certainty is worth more than price. A shorter inspection window, a fully underwritten pre approval instead of a pre qual, and flexibility on the closing date can be worth more to a tired seller than another ten thousand dollars.


  • Ask for the right thing. Find out what they paid and when before you decide what to ask for. Somebody who bought in 2024 with 5% down may physically not be able to take your number no matter how motivated they feel. That seller cannot give you price. They can sometimes give you structure. 


And stop using list price as your measure of leverage. The real indicators are how long it has been sitting and how many times they have already cut. A seller who listed in August and has reduced twice is in a completely different emotional place than one who listed last week.


We got this team.


You are going to be surrounded next Thursday by people who are certain about things they have not fact checked.


That is most of us, most of the time, about most things. I do it too.


But this particular subject, the housing market, happens to be the one where the facts are genuinely more interesting than the vibes. Sales at a sixteen year low with almost no distress in them. Record prices in the worst sales month since 2010. A central bank whose main lever reaches a smaller slice of this market every year. Asking prices that have been falling for 43 straight weeks…


Don’t be like Cersei.  Don’t choose violence.  Choose facts.


Shivani Peterson is the Chief Performance Officer at All Western Mortgage and founder of Mind Over Markets. She holds a master's degree in Marriage and Family Therapy and writes weekly about the intersection of real estate, mortgage markets, and the psychology of financial decision-making. This is not financial advice. It is however, the most honest read on this market you will find on a Friday morning.

 
 
bottom of page