top of page

The People Buying Homes Now Don't Need Me

Nov 13
8 min read

I spend most of my week talking to people about interest rates. It is the first question in every conversation, the thing every client leads with, the number my whole industry organizes itself around.  Last week we rode a blue wave and were hopeful about rates – this week we ran back into the red with the 10YR crossing 5% again, pushing mortgage rates right back up.


This week two reports landed that made me wonder how much that number – the 30 year fixed interest rate - still explains.


One of them was an inflation report that nobody can actually read. The other was a portrait of who is actually buying homes in America right now.


The Inflation Report With No Inflation Rate


October CPI came out Tuesday and the Bureau of Labor Statistics did not publish a 12-month rate. Not for headline inflation. Not for core.


Becaaauuuse….


There was a federal government shutdown from October 1 to November 12 of last year. During that window, BLS did not collect prices. No prices collected in October 2025 means there is no base to compare October 2026 against, which means the annual inflation rate for this month cannot be calculated at all.


It comes back on December 10 with the November report. Now hold that next to this. The Fed makes its next rate decision on December 9.


One day earlier.  They’ll be missing key information on the inflation trend.  And then the next day, the government might shut down again because the current band aid keeping them open since that last shutdown runs out.


What We Do Know


The monthly numbers were published, and both of the ones that matter came in hot.


  • Headline: up 0.4% for the month. Forecasters were at 0.3%.


  • Core: up 0.3%. Forecasters were at 0.2%. That is two months in a row at 0.3%.


  • Shelter: up 0.3%, which is an improvement from 0.4% in September.


  • Gasoline: up 1.0% for the month, and up 37.4% from a year ago.


Gasoline is still writing this story. Thirty seven percent in a year on the one line item every household feels weekly.


Shelter cooling to 0.3% is the good news nobody will report, but it matters because shelter is roughly a quarter of the whole basket.


25 or 50bps?


The CPI numbers all but guaranteed a rate hike from the Fed. The market is now pricing that at 100% odds, which is part of the recent mortgage rates took such a beating this week.  Fed Governor Christopher Waller has said he leans toward a quarter point hike in December. 


But then he said a half point should be considered if core CPI came in around 0.3 percent or higher.


Core came in at 0.3 percent.


So now the question isn’t whether or not they hike, it’s will they have the balls to hike 50bps?  I’d like to go ahead and place a bet.  You see the market has already reacted to a hike, mortgage rates have priced in the December hike.  If the Fed stands tall and says they are serious about inflation and does a half point hike – I’d like to wager mortgage rates improve on the news.


Now the Part That Actually Changed My Thinking


The National Association of Realtors published its annual Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers last week. It is the survey I look forward to most every year because it describes real people instead of aggregates.  As you may know, I’m really into people and their behaviors. 


This year it describes a market you may not recognize…


One in Four Buyers Paid Cash


Roughly one in four buyers in this survey paid cash. No loan at all. In 2019 that number was 12%. It has more than doubled. Among repeat buyers it is 30%. And repeat buyers are 78% of all purchases.


Holy…I already said balls in this blog, I probably shouldn’t swear too.  But look at those numbers together. Nearly four out of five transactions involve someone who already owned a home, and almost a third of that group is not borrowing anything.  No mortgage needed.


So when the Fed raises rates to cool housing demand, there is a large and growing share of this market that simply does not care.


The Median Repeat Buyer Is 62 Years Old


In 1981 the median repeat buyer was 36.  They had a child or two already and were purchasing a home to raise the family in.


Today they are 62, and their top stated reason for moving is to be closer to friends and family. Not a job. Not a school district. Proximity to people they love. Their median household income is $127,000, and many of them are moving with decades of equity behind them.


That is who is transacting in America right now. Not the thirty two year old couple with a baby on the way and a pre approval letter that’s buying power is fading daily as interest rates jump. The person buying a home right now is in their 60’s with equity and options.


And Then There Are the People Trying to Get In


First-time buyers are 22% of the market. That is up from last year, which was the lowest on record.  I’ll take some good news wherever I can get it these days!


However, their median age is 40. In 2010 it was 30. We have added a decade to the start of homeownership. Their median household income is now $100,000, up from $94,400. Their median down payment is 9%.


But get this:


A record 10% of first-time buyers paid all cash. Their median age is 54, against 38 for the ones who financed. And 28% of those cash first-timers used an inheritance to do it, compared with 9% of the ones who took a mortgage. There is now a meaningful group of Americans whose path into their first home will never involve me.


Nobody Is Moving


The typical seller had owned their home for 12 years, an all-time high. Between 2000 and 2008 that number was six.  Buyers in this survey expect to stay a median of 20 years. And 26% say they never expect to move again.


A quarter of the people who bought a house this year believe it is the last house they will ever buy.


That is what a decade of the lock-in effect does. It stops being a rate problem and becomes an inventory crisis.


What People Are Doing to Survive It


The adaptations in this data are where I came back to life, because strategy is everything.


  • Roommates. 5% of buyers purchased with a roommate. That is a 45 year high.


  • Multigenerational. 14% bought a multigenerational home. Among buyers with children under 18, buying together specifically to reduce childcare costs jumped from 11% last year to 16% this year. I feel that.


  • Location logic flipped. Buyers choosing a home for job convenience dropped to 31%, from 52% in 2014. Choosing for proximity to friends and family rose to 46% - I wonder what that tells us about mental health in America…


  • Compromise. 34% of first-time buyers compromised on price, 28% on size, 26% on condition. The typical first-time home is 1,600 square feet against 2,000 for repeat buyers.


People are restructuring their entire lives around the math rather than giving up on owning a home. Buying with a sibling. Moving in with a parent. Taking the smaller house, the worse condition, the further neighborhood.


Back to my point about mental health. The data shows us people used to choose where to live based on where they worked. Now they choose based on who is nearby. When the financial case gets hard enough, people fall back on the only return that still pencils, which is being close to the people they love.


Why These Two Reports Are the Same Story


The Fed has one real tool. It raises and lowers the cost of borrowing money, and it uses that to speed up or slow down the economy.


That tool works only on people who borrow.


A quarter of homebuyers right now are not borrowing. Nearly a third of repeat buyers are not borrowing. The median buyer in the largest segment of this market is 62 years old and sitting on equity from a house they bought in a different century.


So the Fed raises rates to cool housing, and the part of the market that actually gets cooled is the first-time buyer, who is already down to 22% of transactions and already waiting until 40 to get in.


Higher rates are selecting who gets to participate in this market rather than cooling it evenly. And the selection keeps landing on the same people.


Meanwhile the Fed is about to make that decision on December 9 using a report that has no annual inflation rate in it, about a shelter component that is already cooling, driven by a gasoline problem that monetary policy cannot touch.


Every part of this should bother you, at least a little.


Where This Complicates Something I Told You


Three weeks ago I made a prediction and said I would report back either way, so here I am doing that early.


I argued that the collapse in pending home sales was too big to be explained by rates, and that the gap was people refusing to act for reasons that had nothing to do with math. I called it the Confidence Tax. Then I said that if rates turned and demand recovered, I would owe you a correction.


This week’s data suggests a third possibility that I did not put on the table…


The people who can still transact in this market were never especially rate sensitive to begin with. They are older, they have equity, a quarter of them are paying cash. Rates coming down does not change much for them because rates going up did not change much for them either.


And the people who are rate sensitive, the first-time buyers, are so far from qualifying that twenty basis points is noise. It physically pains me to say that but it might be true.


Which would mean the November number I told you to watch may not settle the argument at all. It might just confirm that the marginal buyer, the one who actually responds to a rate change, has already left the building.


I still think the Confidence Tax is real and I have watched it cost people real money. I’m saying the story about the American Dream is gaining nuance by the day.


What should you do this info?


I opened by saying I spend my whole week talking about rates.


I am not going to stop, because for the person sitting across from me trying to buy their first house, the rate is still the thing that decides whether the answer is yes. That has not changed and I am not going to pretend otherwise.  If you are trying to buy, you are competing with cash more than you are competing with other borrowers.


That changes what you should be optimizing for. Speed and certainty are worth more than they used to be. A fully underwritten pre approval, a short inspection window, a seller who actually needs a clean close rather than a fast one. Those are the places a financed buyer can still win.


But this week was a useful reminder that the number I organize my life around is becoming less and less descriptive of the market as a whole. A quarter of buyers are not listening to it. The Fed is about to move it without being able to see the thing it is aiming at. And the people most affected by it have the least say in any of it.


If you are in that last group, the thing I would tell you is that waiting for the rate is a strategy that assumes you are the person the rate is being set for. The data this week says you probably are not.



Shivani Peterson is the Chief Performance Officer at All Western Mortgage and founder of Mind Over Markets. She holds a master's degree in Marriage and Family Therapy and writes weekly about the intersection of real estate, mortgage markets, and the psychology of financial decision-making. This is not financial advice. It is however, the most honest read on this market you will find on a Friday morning.

 
 
bottom of page