top of page

The Bond Market Voted

Nov 6
6 min read

Remember when I told you to stop reading election analysis and watch one number instead?  (It was last week.)


I said the commentary would be written by people who have never traced how an election actually reaches a mortgage rate, and that the 10-year Treasury would tell you what the bond market concluded within about forty eight hours.  The bond market would be your most credible, unbiased source of information.


So let me hold myself to it, because I was right, and I love being right.  


What the Number Said


Democrats took the House and the Senate. That produces divided government, with a Democratic Congress and a Republican White House, and the expectation of very little large legislation getting through either way.  Not saying this is a good thing, just explaining.


The 10-year Treasury fell to 4.84% by midday Thursday. That is the lowest level since September 10, and it is a long way down from the 5.30% readings in early October. Every maturity on the Treasury curve fell at least three basis points.


This is what I told you would happen. Less capacity to pass spending means less borrowing, which means less Treasury issuance, which means more buyers chasing the same supply of bonds, which means yields fall and your mortgage rate follows.


Since I don’t want to toot my own horn too much, you should know this is apparently the normal pattern rather than a surprise. Since the mid-1990s, the 10-year has averaged an 18 basis point decline in the month following a midterm that produced a split Congress or a split government.


Three Weeks Down


The 30-year fixed came in at 7.18% in this morning's Freddie Mac survey. The 15-year is at 6.57%. For reference, a year ago those were 6.22% and 5.50%.


That is the third consecutive weekly decline but we are not talking about a meaningful difference/improvement….yet.


AI again.


The election was not the only thing moving money into Treasuries this week.


The AI trade cracked.


The Nasdaq fell as much as 5% on Thursday and is now in correction territory, roughly 10% below its October 6 record. The semiconductor index dropped as much as 11%, its worst session since March 2020. Nvidia fell almost 9%. AMD lost more than 15%. Micron, Marvell, Arm, Dell, Qualcomm all took double digit losses.


Long story short, there is a move away from chipmakers and it is creating "a bid for Treasuries."


I have been making an argument all year that I want to revisit now that half of it is on the table.


My argument has been that if AI succeeds rates will go in the same direction as if it implodes.  I’ll elaborate. If AI delivers real productivity, the effect is structurally deflationary and rates come down. If AI disappoints, investors dump risk and run into the safety of Treasury bonds, demand for Treasuries spikes, yields fall, and…rates come down.


In states where data centers are a major concern, like Texas – candidates who would stop their development were elected. Not good news for neocloud stocks.  So capital left the AI trade creating a flight to safety in mortgage bonds.  Remember, higher demand for mortgage bonds brings mortgage rates down.


The Part That Is Actually About Housing


A few weeks ago I wrote about builders losing the bidding war for skilled labor. Electricians, pipefitters, concrete crews, heavy equipment operators, all of them being hired away by hyperscalers putting up data centers who are not price sensitive on labor the way a residential developer with a thin pro forma has to be. Less crew for housing means fewer units finished, and fewer units finished in 2028 means higher rents. 

Two developments on that front…


  • Voters pushed back. Reuters reported that Tuesday's elections passed dozens of ballot measures that could limit data center construction.  As mentioned above.


  • The money got harder. Selling across both stock and bond markets has made it meaningfully harder for data center builders to raise money, and hyperscalers are issuing more equity and debt as free cash flow falls.


Put those together and the single largest competitor for residential construction labor could be stalled and more expensive to fund, by public vote and by capital markets at the same time.


I realize this isn’t the biggest story this week but I think it’s one to watch over the next 12 months. It could be genuinely good news for housing supply in 2028… 


And Then the Jobs Report


The October jobs report landed at 5:30 am Pacific to turn everything upside down. The economy added 165,000 jobs in October. Economists were looking for 59,000. That is nearly three times the forecast. The unemployment rate fell to 4.1% from 4.2%. Average hourly earnings rose 0.4% for the month to $38.00, up 3.1% over the year.


And then…


The revisions went up. August was revised from 133,000 to 186,000. September was revised from 29,000 to 60,000. Together those two months are 84,000 stronger than we were told they were.


What the Market Did 


Yields went up on the news. The 2-year rose six basis points to 4.52%. The 10-year rose three to 4.87%. The 30-year rose two to 5.27%.


Odds of a December hike jumped to roughly 78%, up from about 70% before the report.


Peter Cardillo at Spartan Capital said the data "just confirms that the Fed has no choice but to raise rates in December," and then asked the question I think is going to be the actual market mover which is whether it ends up being twenty five basis points or fifty.


Susannah Streeter at Wealth Club said it makes a cut less likely near term and strengthens the case for higher for longer. Joe Saluzzi at Themis Trading was the lone voice of restraint, saying he would not raise rates on this data alone given how volatile markets have been this week.


Brian Jacobsen at Annex Wealth made the one genuinely hopeful point, which is that lower oil prices could still ease the pressure to hike.


Kara Ng at Zillow called it an open question whether the forces holding yields up can sustainably fade, and Zillow is still forecasting rates above 7% through the middle of 2027. Stephen Dover at Franklin Templeton pointed out that deficits and Treasury issuance do not disappear because of one election. 


The Confidence Tax


I can’t even listen to myself explain the opportunities a buyer has right now anymore, I’m sick of the sound of my own voice.  I will say this, because the opportunity is so very real.  The lack of confidence this year has been expensive, justified because the world is a wild place right now, but expensive.  The cost of waiting numbers I’ve calculated for you over the past few weeks are insane.  And the leverage buyers have is historical.


But the market has felt frozen.  Listings sitting, sellers willing to negotiate.  Buyers who can’t afford to buy, mentally or financially.  So they just stare each other down…


Now that midterm elections are over and we are seeing some improvement in mortgage rates, will we see more activity over the next few weeks?  Please share your thoughts in the comments, will the Confidence Tax start to lift now that we have some answers about what the next two years look like?


In other news…


P.S. I’ve been following @theficouple on Instagram for years. (My dream is to bring them out for a Future is Female event.) They are former social workers who went from $100,000 in debt to building a multimillion-dollar real estate portfolio and making work optional in their 30s.  IN THEIR 30’s. They did it without a trust fund and now teach others how to invest without having tens of thousands of dollars. 


On November 17 at 8 PM ET, they're hosting a FREE live workshop revealing how they acquired 16 rental units using creative financing and low- and no-money-down strategies. 

You'll learn practical ways to find deals, finance properties creatively, and build wealth through real estate.



Shivani Peterson is the Chief Performance Officer at All Western Mortgage and founder of Mind Over Markets. She holds a master's degree in Marriage and Family Therapy and writes weekly about the intersection of real estate, mortgage markets, and the psychology of financial decision-making. This is not financial advice. It is however, the most honest read on this market you will find on a Friday morning. 

 
 
bottom of page